My Top Five Virgin Islands Cocktails

So you visited the British Virgin Islands and you partook in all the local drink specialties, but now you’re back home and wondering how to recreate that holiday magic – never fear, I’m here to help!! Keep reading for the recipes to my top 5 Virgin Islands cocktail recipes.


This Painkiller was consumed at Soggy Dollar Bar, Jost Van Dyke

If you came to visit the BVI and left without trying a Painkiller then I am sorry to tell you that you need to go back and try again…

The quintessential British Virgin Islands cocktail, there is some disagreement as to the origin of the cocktail with two bars renowned for the Painkiller (Pusser’s and the Soggy Dollar). Pusser’s fans insist that a Painkiller can really only be made with Pusser’s Navy rum, while the Soggy Dollar uses Cruzan. But even Pusser’s concede that their Painkiller recipe is inspired by Daphne Henderson at the Soggy Dollar Bar.

Whichever one you believe to be the rightful owner of that honor, there’s no denying that you really have to try one in order to consider your Virgin Islands experience complete – extra points for consuming it with your toes in the sand.

The exact recipe and ratios at Soggy Dollar are a carefully guarded secret – but you can start by using this recipe below:

2 oz Rum (Cruzan is my preference but you can also used flavored rums to add a few different variations)
1 oz Coconut Cream (Coco Lopez)
4 oz Pineapple Juice
1 oz Orange Juice
Grated Nutmeg to garnish

 Painkillers taste best when you shake all your non-alcoholic ingredients together and then add the rum. Stir, grate over nutmeg and serve.

Note: the non-alcoholic ingredients can be mixed in advance and then poured over rum and ice if you fancy taking it with you to the beach or on a boat trip!


Is it a drink? Is it a dessert? Who knows!? But it’s damn tasty and ridiculously boozy! Said to have been invented in St. Thomas in the 1970s, it was allegedly named after a dog at the Ship’s Store and Sapphire Pub named Bushwhack.

This frozen concoction is surprisingly strong with at least 5 different spirits (depending on whose recipe you follow, I like to use 6…) blended together to create this deceptively sweet and creamy milkshake treat. If you fancy recreating that at home you can use the recipe below:

1 oz Vodka
1 oz Coconut Rum
1 oz Baileys
1 oz Amaretto
1 oz Kahlua
1 oz Creme de Cacao (optional)
1 oz Coconut Cream (Coco Lopez)
Chocolate Sauce and whipped cream to garnish

 Throw everything into a blender with a cup of ice and blend until smooth and creamy. Drizzle chocolate sauce on the inside of your glass before adding your Bushwhacker mixture.

Dark n’ Stormy:

This Dark n’ Stormy was consumed at CocoMaya, Virgin Gorda

Originating in Bermuda – the Dark n’ Stormy has been adopted elsewhere in the Caribbean, including the BVI. We love it so much we even named a sailing regatta after it (a three day race event from Trellis Bay to Anegada and back to Nanny Cay). I think that my favorite Dark n’ Stormy’s can be found on the Willy-T, but they are a staple on the menu in bars Territory-wide.

2 oz Dark Rum (Gosling’s Black Seal)
couple dashes of Angostura Bitters
4 oz Ginger Beer
Lime to garnish

Fill glass with ice and combine the rum, ginger beer and angostura bitters. Garnish with a generous wedge of lime to squeeze in.

Dark n Stormy Multihulls MagazineThe Classic Rum Punch:

This Rum Punch was consumed at Hog Heaven, Virgin Gorda

A list of Caribbean cocktails would not be complete without a classic rum punch. There are likely as many variations of rum punch as there are islands and cays in the Caribbean. Made with a variety of different recipes across the Territory, it is typically sweet, sour and fruity with the distinguishable red hue given by the Grenadine syrup.

2 oz Dark Rum
1/4 oz Grenadine Syrup
2 oz Orange Juice
2 oz Pineapple Juice
Other tropical fruit juices also encouraged
Generous squeeze of Lime or splash of sour mix
Dash of Angostura Bitters
Wedge of Pineapple or Orange and a Maraschino Cherry to garnish

 Combine your rum and chosen fruit juices in a highball glass over ice. Squeeze in lime juice and add a dash of angostura bitters. Garnish with extra fruit.

Ting with a Sting (or Ting with Anything)

Ting is such a distinctive Caribbean soft drink. Originally made in Jamaica in the 1970s it is a grapefruit flavored soda that is both sweet and tart and immediately invokes memories of beach bars and palm trees. One of the beauties of Ting is that it goes really well with a variety of different spirits.

Rum and Ting? Works!
Vodka and Ting? Yes please!
Gin and Ting? Delicious!

2 oz Spirit of choice
5 oz Ting Grapefruit Soda

These cocktails should be available in some guise at any bar in the BVI. It’s time for you to visit and find your favorites!

So whether you’re practicing these in advance of your Virgin Islands holiday – or trying them when you get back home to try and combat the post-holiday blues. You can now make them at home and create your own little tropical staycation. Bonus points if you brought back authentic ingredients like Cruzan Rum, BVI Gin or Gosling’s.

If you need more information about where to eat and enjoy cocktails in the BVI – check out my restaurant guide here.

Ting Multihulls Magazine

About The Author


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.